T he 354th fighter group, dubbed pioneers, started flying p51bs over france in december, 1943. Furthermore, one must stipulate the precise versions in order to answer this question defensibly, since both of. The north american p 51 mustang was involved in one of the unusual twists of world war ii. Overall id hand the edge to the dora9, if i remember correctly it had the edge in speed and if the two were to have met in larger numbers it would have been at altitudes better suited to the focke wulf, having said that i would expect the p 51d to do better at lower levels were the fw 190 did not excell. Evers and alfred gassner, both of whom had worked for american aviation firms, while the design team of the premier american fighter, the north american p51 mustang, was led by edgar schmued, who had formerly worked for. Discover the history of a classic duel as the finest american and german pilots are pitted against each other in the wartorn skies over europe, in two of the most advanced fighter planes of the age, the p 51 mustang and the fw 190. Available download in pdf format for desktop pc or mac and ios or android mobile devices.
P51a mustang ii production was divided between america and britain. Men at arms books osprey publishing internet archive. Please read our short guide how to send a book to kindle. The p51as allison engine was powerful, but its streng. Fw s have better roll rate, which helps them in evading p 51 s if they know how. Comparison of north american p51 mustang and fockewulf fw 190 wurger direct sidebyside comparison of two aircraft. Because pilot skill is often what determines the fight in neither the bf 109, fw 190, or p 51d can you haul on the stick and get out of trouble. The north american p51 mustang was involved in one of the unusual twists of world war ii. Shrike is a german singleseat, singleengine fighter. P51 mustang vs fw 190 europe 194345 is the debut title in ospreys duel series. In fact, the p 38 became the model for combat aircraft of the future, which utilized speed, altitude capability and firepower to defeat more maneuverable opponents. This first book in a new series describes the design and development of these rivals and analyzes the strengths and weaknesses of each fighter through an. Here, we are told of the duel between the american p 51 mustang and the german fw 190.
History commissioned by royal air force in april 1941 to north american aviation inc. Shrike is a german singleseat, single engine fighter. P51 mustang page 2 service in the eto, table of aces, and postwar. One of the most effective, famous and beautiful fighter aircraft of wwii, the p51 was designed to fulfill a british requirement dated april 1940. Fw190 dora9 vs p51d mustang aircraft of world war ii. P51 mustang compared to other airplanes jim brooks. The fw 190a really didnt stink compared to the p51 mustang. To be truthful, when i first heard about this new series i was curious as to how it was to be presented and fearful that it would just. T he 354th fighter group, dubbed pioneers, started flying p 51bs over france in december, 1943. Fast, and with an exceptional rate of climb, it quickly bettered. The fw 190f and fw 190g series were parallel fighterbomber developments. Shrike adalah sebuah pesawat tempur berkursi tunggal dan bermesin tunggal buatan jerman yang dirancang oleh kurt tank pada akhir tahun 1930an dan digunakan selama perang dunia ii. North american aviation p51 d mustang trisha basuray matthew janeway william walker. An innovation it had was electricallyoperated control surfaces.
The classic lines of a p51 mustang need no explanation. Europe 194345 duel by martin bowman english september 18, 2007 isbn. Overall id hand the edge to the dora9, if i remember correctly it had the edge in speed and if the two were to have met in larger numbers it would have been at altitudes better suited to the focke wulf, having said that i would expect the p51d to do better at lower levels were the fw190 did not excell. Along with its wellknown counterpart, the messerschmitt bf 109, the fw 190 became the backbone of the luftwaffes jagdwaffe fighter force.
Because pilot skill is often what determines the fight in neither the bf 109, fw 190, or p51d. The versatile german junkers ju 88 bomber was created by a design team led by w. The north american aviation p51 mustang is an american longrange, singleseat fighter and. May 08, 20 it was even longer ranging than the p 51 mustang, and when utilized correctly, was difficult to beat in aerial combat. Comparison of north american p51 mustang and fockewulf. The fockewulf fw 190 wurger was used by the luftwaffe during the second. One of the main reasons why the p51 was faster than the fw 190 and the bf109 was not only because it was better aerodynamically with less drag but it could produce more power even with a smaller engine, 27 litre compared the 42 litre of the fw 190 and 34 litre of the bf109 and it could do this at the high altitudes where the bombers flew. Flying the forktailed devil a p38 pursuit pilot remembers. In an attempt to learn the wonderful fw190d9 dora module, im flying through the included campaign missions. This one, flying solo against a pair of mustangs made of pure stalinium really gave.
The test was between an f4u1d, an f6f3 and a fw190. Nr 270 was the first 190 to have the engine mount extended by 15 cm 6 in, which would be standardized on the later production a5 model. Collect the best, the rarest and most significant technical documents from the 1930s and 40s and republish for engineers, advanced model makers, cad engineers, museums. B1 b17 b24 b25 b26 b29 b36 b45 b47 b52 b57 b58 b707 c ch47 clippers connie dc123 fw190 f4f f4u f6f f7f f8f f9f f82 f84 f86 f89 f3df10 f4d f 100 f101 f102106 f. The system was designed and flown in a matter of months and made such an impact that it could clearly be considered the warwinning design for the allies. Fw190 had an engine as powerful as p47 thunderbolt but was sleeker and smaller. Data from erection and maintenance manual for p51d and p51k, p51.
Another american fighter aircraft, the north american p51 mustang, entered service. The fw190a really didnt stink compared to the p51 mustang. Kurt buhligen, the thirdhighest scoring german fighter pilot of world war iis western front with 112 confirmed victories, three against mustangs, later stated, we would outturn the p51 and the other american fighters, with the bf 109 or the fw 190. North american p51 mustang wikipedia republished wiki 2. Nov 20, 2016 in an attempt to learn the wonderful fw 190 d9 dora module, im flying through the included campaign missions. I love the p 51d versus the bf 109 fw 190 matchup maybe more than any other in warbirds. The mustang was designed in 1940 by north american aviation naa in response to a requirement of the british purchasing commission. All were based on fw 190 a series airframes modified in various ways. I really feel you guys are making the dora out to be a super ac against the p51. The longnosed dora 9, designed by kurt tank, first appeared in the skies over the western and eastern fronts in the late summer of. Digital copy duel book series no 1 p51 mustang vs fw 190. Shrike is a german singleseat, singleengine fighter aircraft designed by kurt tank in the late 1930s and widely used during world war ii.
The mustang was conceived, designed and built by north american aviation naa in response to a specification issued directly to naa by the british purchasing commission. The north american aviation p51 mustang is an american longrange, singleseat fighter and fighterbomber used during world war ii and the korean war, among other conflicts. Any collection strong in military aircraft history will welcome the specifics on combat. Discover the history of a classic duel as the finest american and german pilots are pitted against each other in the wartorn skies over europe, in two of the most advanced fighter planes of the age, the p51 mustang and the fw 190. P47c thunderbolt vs fw 190 butcherbird altitude 25,000 feet.
The legendary p51 mustang, the finest american fighter of world war ii, versus the fw 190a, one of germanys greatest pistonengined interceptors, provided some of the most deadly combat confrontations of the war in europe. To be honest, i find the p51s to be superior to 190s. It was even longer ranging than the p51 mustang, and when utilized correctly, was difficult to beat in aerial combat. The fw190a5 could make about 422mph at near 20,000 feet and climb there at 2100 feet per minute. North american aviation p51 d mustang virginia tech. The north american p51 mustang proved an invaluable addition to the allied cause in the latter half of world war 2. Here, we are told of the duel between the american p51 mustang and the german fw190. The basic premise of this new dual series is to compare allied fighter aircraft, tanks and ships with their axis adversaries. Bersama dengan bf109, fw 190 menjadi salah satu tulang punggung jagdwaffe pasukan. Which is the better ww2 fighter plane the fw 190 or the. Mar 27, 2009 the p 51 mustang is a much better planeit had much better performance and better weapons.
To find out why, lets compare the two aircraft in terms of performance. See more ideas about p51 mustang, mustang and fighter jets. To be honest, i find the p 51 s to be superior to 190 s. So fw 190 a5 vs p51 realistic battle discussion war. To get 70% off with the nordvpn 3year deal plus 1 month free with the coupon code curiousdroid deal here. The p51 mustang is a much better planeit had much better performance and better weapons. Then again, a good p 51d driver can cause a reverse result just as often. You are correct about the 391mph speed reached by the hellcat. The twinrow bmw 801 radial engine that powered most operational versions. Internal armament was reduced to the cowl mounted mg and the 220mm cannon in the wing roots. The mustang was designed in april 1940 by a design team headed by james kindelberger of north american aviation naa in response to a requirement of the british purchasing commission. The mustang was designed in 1940 by north american aviation naa in response to a requirement of the british purchasing commission for licensebuilt curtiss p 40 fighters. Jan 26, 2012 p 51 mustang page 2 service in the eto, table of aces, and postwar. Kupte knihu p51 mustang vs fw 190 martin bowman za 505 kc v overenem obchode.
Fw 190a and optical fiber communication lecture notes pdf spitfire v 5. The fact that fw 190 s were slaughtered in late 4445, is entirely due to the shortages of properly trained pilots and fuel, the fighter itself simply cannot be blamed. P51 mustang vs fw190 the nemesis of p51 wasnt the jet me262 it was the radialengine fw190. Jan 16, 2017 it strongly depends on things such as altitude advantage surprise factor plane variant the first p 51 variants were, quite frankly, trash planes to be fighting in the european theater.
Because of the rapidlymounting clouds of war in europe, the uk asked north american aircraft to design and build a new fighter in only 120 days. Firing time pts main gun firing time pts secondary guns firing time pts total main gun rate of fire roundmin main gun effective range yd main gun effective range m turn radius no flaps turn radius full flaps. As far as dogfighting is concerned is that its easier to get a kill if you are flying the mustang but its not that easy, for a number of reasons. Like the fw 190 and spitfire, the p51 was a pilots airplane. It strongly depends on things such as altitude advantage surprise factor plane variant the first p51 variants were, quite frankly, trash planes to be fighting in the european theater. Arguably two of the finest pistonengined fighters ever built, the tempest v and fw 190d9 raised the bar in terms of aircraft design and operational capability during world war ii. Fockewulf fw 190 operational history military wiki fandom. Evers and alfred gassner, both of whom had worked for american aviation firms, while the design team of the premier american fighter, the north american p 51 mustang, was led by edgar schmued, who had formerly worked for. This site contains a large collection new and rare digital magazines, books, manuals and more.
The north american aviation p51 mustang is an american longrange, single seat fighter and. Because these two warplanes never fought each other in reality one must first admit that nothing definitive can be said on this matter. The role of the p51 in the defeat of the german air force in world war two a thesis submitted to the graduate faculty of the louisiana state university and agricultural and mechanical college in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in the department of history by. The fw 190a really didnt stink compared to the p 51 mustang. North american p51 mustang singleseat, singleengine. North american aviation p 51 d mustang trisha basuray matthew janeway william walker. The 109s are competitve enough with the p38s that i dont think its completely unfair for german teams as a whole, but if a p51 d30 gets downtiered against a team of 4. In level flight, the mustang is faster than the 190. The singleseat fockewulf fw190 fighter aircraft helped to even the. The purchasing commission approached north american aviation to build curtiss p40.
Fw 190 europe 194345 by martin bowman tells of the history of a classic duel as american and german pilots fought each other over europe, offering the first in a new series to describe the design and deployment of these fighters. The tests were conducted at standard fighter overload weight and all airspeed indicators were properly calibrated per the report. Jun 06, 2016 4k best of hangar 10 fly in 2019 focke wulf 190, messerschmitt bf 109, p51 mustang, spitfire duration. The legendary p 51 mustang, the finest american fighter of world war ii, versus the fw 190a, one of germanys greatest pistonengined interceptors, provided some of the most deadly combat confrontations of the war in europe. Originally part of the ninth air force, the 354th was loaned to. Data from erection and maintenance manual for p51d and p 51k, p51. The fw 190a5 could make about 422mph at near 20,000 feet and climb there at 2100 feet per minute. All were heavily armed, the fw 190 with as many as two 7. Your selected aircraft are compared in sidebyside arrangement below.
The fw 190g1 was a long range fighterbomber variant based on the a4 airframe and used the bmw 801d2 engine. I love the p51d versus the bf 109fw 190 matchup maybe more than any other in warbirds. Jun 04, 2003 the test was between an f4u1d, an f6f3 and a fw 190. Sep 23, 2017 the north american aviation p 51 mustang is an american longrange, singleseat fighter and fighterbomber used during world war ii, the korean war and other conflicts. Fws have better roll rate, which helps them in evading p51s if they know how. This is a ticky one because the two were designed with such different roles in mind.
1279 490 150 804 834 522 1441 1460 1208 730 783 841 1027 1082 1415 1027 736 869 1446 1560 285 334 484 671 609 767 246 918 30 252 435 701 677 401 1287 975 297 1188